...no. I think that's fairly reasonable, given our circumstances.

[Unfortunately, he doesn't have much of an alibi at all, but Jonathan is nothing if not honest.]

Truthfully, I barely remember anything before a few moments ago. There was a flash of lightning, the crash of thunder...and then I was standing here with this egg in my hand. I'm not even certain of where this place is, or why I have found myself here.

I know that might not be the ideal answer, but it's the only one I can give.