So the answer must be 2! If the butler made the tea, but someone else killed him, then...it must have been a dispute between the butler and the killer! The butler had to have been in on it if he drugged you, and then they had a falling out...right?

[Yuna's pretty sure she's onto something, but Togo is definitely the smarter of the two, so it's always best to check her answers.

She's definitely stealing this plot for their next hero play, though.]